INTERNATIONAL EDITION / Volume 01PEOPLE, CULTURE & A WIDER WORLD
Saved 0
WAYFARER

THE CURATED EDITION.

Brief /

Defender or Copy? Jaguar Land Rover Takes BYD to Court

The British maker claims BYD took a Defender apart to build the Ti7, an off-roader due in the UK in January at a far lower price.

WAYFARER · Motoring

There is a fine line between inspiration and imitation, and Jaguar Land Rover has decided that BYD crossed it. According to The Times of London, the British manufacturer has formally accused the Chinese giant of infringing its intellectual property. At the heart of the dispute is the Ti7, an off-roader BYD is preparing for the British market. In JLR’s reading, it is not a rival to the Defender. It is a replica.

The suspicion is not new. Ever since BYD announced plans to bring the model to Britain, having first launched it in China under its Fangchengbao brand, the resemblance to the Defender has been impossible to ignore. Top Gear went as far as calling it a “Chinese Defender clone”.

Land Rover Defender off road
The Defender, at the centre of Jaguar Land Rover’s claim.

A search in the Netherlands

JLR took the matter to court earlier this year. In August, acting on a court order, bailiffs searched BYD’s offices in the Netherlands and seized digital records, The Times reports. JLR alleges that BYD dismantled a Defender and reverse-engineered parts of its technology for the Ti7, and that the search was needed to secure evidence before it could disappear.

BYD says it has cooperated fully, describes the action as a “fishing expedition” and argues that far too many files were taken. JLR reportedly chose the Netherlands because its courts are seen as favourable to intellectual property claims. A preliminary hearing this week will decide whether the case goes ahead.

“JLR does not comment on ongoing legal proceedings,” a company spokesperson said. BYD did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

The pressure from China

The case arrives at a delicate moment. Another Chinese brand, Jaecoo, is already unsettling JLR with its 7, an SUV nicknamed the “Temu Range Rover” in Britain. It costs around $13,300 less than the original, according to The Guardian, and became the UK’s best-selling car in October, shortly after launch. The Ti7, due in British showrooms in January, is expected to undercut the Defender by around $26,600.


The Defender took decades to turn a square silhouette into a signature. What a Dutch court now begins to weigh is the price of copying a shape that looks simple and never was.

The WAYFARER Editors

Land Rover Defender, the model at the centre of JLR's claim against BYD

CONTINUE READING

Another point of view.

THE CURATED GLOBE / FROM THE EDITORS

Good stories.
Better company.

THE READING ROOM

What catches
your attention?

Culture & People

Culture46 storiesArt & Collecting9 storiesMusic & Nightlife5 stories

Places & Living

Travel99 storiesCities & Addresses7 storiesHomes & Estates9 storiesDesign41 stories

Taste & Wellbeing

Dining31 storiesWine & Spirits9 storiesBeauty & Wellbeing24 stories

Style & Craft

Style66 storiesWatches & Jewellery27 storiesMotoring37 storiesSea & Sky28 stories